Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Extra Extra: MY UNDESIRABLE FRIENDS

Julia Loktev’s My Undesirable Friends is an overwhelming work. It’s a documentary on a vital subject and massive scale. It’s intimate, incisive, and a powerful accumulation of rambling footage of remarkable duration. Spanning several years, several countries, and several personal stories, Loktev has assembled two films running nearly 12 hours total. The first, subtitled Part 1 — Last Air in Moscow, is about a community of independent Russian journalists scrambling to get the truth to their fellow citizens in the run up to the invasion of Ukraine. It’s about the nervous energy of the newsroom, and the camaraderie of coworkers in pursuit of a noble goal. It’s about professional communicators who think very carefully about their rhetoric, choosing words with precision, and urgently fact-checking the increasingly grim news around their country before getting the vital information out. It’s about fear and paranoia as an authoritarian government further consolidates its threatening powers of censorship, imprisonment, and death. The second film, subtitled Part 2 — Exile, finds the community fractured and scattered across eastern Europe, and the world. Now the plan is to continue to report wherever and however they can. Some embedded in the war zone, others working from makeshift digital setups in random hotels and apartments, still more trying to sustain a broadcast whether online or over the air. 

Both films concern themselves with extended meetings and lengthy hangouts. In the former we see the tense back-and-forth prep and negotiations behind the scenes of news organizations, as good as any portrait of journalists at work. In the latter, we see those same people who bring us the news in domestic moments of interpersonal bonding over the work, and over their imperiled and transitory lives. How does one have a life while driven to succeed in such an important public-facing job? It’s difficult enough even if not at a time and in a place in which doing that job might endanger your life. How do you raise a child, care for an elderly relative, plan a married life in such provisional circumstances? That all that is nonetheless attempted under the increasingly arbitrary rules of a regime that’s closing off what little freedom of the press remained—criminalizing dissent, declaring “enemies” of anyone not parroting the official line—gives the first movie a sense of impending disaster, and the second an unsettled lack of certainty. Everything feels temporary. We see the effects of this on a large cast of characters, which gives a multifaceted view of the work and of their relationships to it, and to each other, and to their particular life situations. There are young people just getting started, parents in the middle of their careers, older veterans who’ve been doing the work for decades. There are podcasters and bloggers and more conventional broadcasters. In the first movie they’re all in Russia, in the second they’re (mostly) all out. Loktev uses the same perceptiveness and subtlety she brings to her quietly devastating fiction films (like low-boil terrorist procedural Day Night Day Night or deteriorating engagement story The Loneliest Planet) to this project, allowing us to see the small details of life under this stage of a fascist project attempting to narrow the horizons of the possible. 

Loketev drops us into long sequences of what feels like reality unfolding before our eyes. She embedded in these groups, not as mere recorder, but, as the title suggests, a friend. There’s an intimacy and a lack of false polish to the footage and editing that gives it the rough-hewn vérité of home videos. She shot on cell phones and intercut with news footage and social media screens and Zoom calls and FaceTime. It’s how we see the world these days, as unflinching as raw feeds.  What it lacks in concision and occasional clarity it more than makes up for with immediacy. There’s a constant sense of unfolding reality in all its misshapen indigestible endlessness. We’re always dropped into unfolding vignettes, forced to pick up context clues and piece together the story like they’re piecing together their lives. (If you don’t know recent world history, you’d be a little lost in the details from time to time. I bet annotations will be helpful for future audiences.) We see reactions to the expected bold-faced news items from protests and crackdowns to invasions and deaths. But we also chart the tremors of internal and external tensions on their media projects, from funding to audiences to regulations. The duration of the film is to its benefit, the sheer tonnage of experience it fits into its endless quotidian tensions and chatty conversations. We get to know their faces and their fears. We live with them as the events just keep unfolding, present-tense, rough and rambling, continually moving forward. It’s not a message movie or issue-driven call-to-action as is the mode to which simpler current events docs default. It doesn’t have to stretch for cheap human interest sentiment. It just presents humans in all their particulars for us to see and understand. In such circumstances, even small moments feel weighted. One younger journalist in exile calls his grandfather back in their homeland. The old man sighs, “Everything will be fine. Everything will end tragically.”

No comments:

Post a Comment